New supermini achieves 'respectable' four stars in safety tests, but loses marks for rear passenger whiplash protection
James Attwood, digital editor
9 October 2019

The new Peugeot 208 has missed out on a maximum score in the latest Euro NCAP safety ratings, with testers awarding it four stars.

The French hatch missed out on top marks due to what Euro NCAP testers said was disappointing whiplash protection for rear passengers. The Jeep Cherokee was also awarded four stars in the latest tests, and they are the only two cars tested so far in 2019 that have failed to achieve five stars.

Euro NCAP noted that the 208 "narrowly" missed a five-star rating. The previous generation 208 achieved the maximum score when it was tested in 2012, but Euro NCAP noted that its tests had been toughened since then, so the new machine still represents a step forward, and is fitted with more standard-fit safety technology.

Matthew Avery, director of research at Thatcham Research, which conducts Euro NCAP tests, called the 208’s score “respectable”, but added it was “not a good choice if you’re carrying adults in the back, with its ‘poor’ whiplash protection for rear passengers. Protecting both front and rear occupants is especially important as families continue to downsize from larger vehicles.”

The Cherokee was described by Euro NCAP as sitting "squarely in four-star territory", due to "good but unexceptional performance across the board."

lost marks for both adult occupant protection and child occupant protection, and was criticised for offering limited whiplash protection. Avery called the result an improvement on the Jeep Wrangler, which scored one star when tested last year, but added: “There’s still a long way to go before Jeep can get back to producing five-star cars like the 2017 Compass.”

Two BMW models excelled when they were tested, with the 1 Series and 3 Series both scoring the maximum five stars. The 3 Series achieved a 97% score for adult occupant protection, one of the highest scores in 2019.

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

Euro NCAP secretary general Michiel van Ratingen said: "I'm sure that BMW's customers can be confident that the company will continue to strive for the highest standards of safety."

Read more

First drive: New Peugeot 208 1.2 Allure

Jeep Wrangler scores one star in Euro NCAP testing

Tesla Model 3 shines in latest Euro NCAP tests

Join the debate

Comments
7

9 October 2019

I,m sure Peugeotr will   have fix  soon as they dont want to be seen as what is a backward steep in safety

9 October 2019
Antony Riley wrote:

I,m sure Peugeotr will   have fix  soon as they dont want to be seen as what is a backward steep in safety

 

Anytime soon, xxxx will repeat your statement and claim the obvious for itself.

9 October 2019
Takeitslowly wrote:
Antony Riley wrote:

I,m sure Peugeotr will   have fix  soon as they dont want to be seen as what is a backward steep in safety

 

Anytime soon, xxxx will repeat your statement and claim the obvious for itself.

 

Isn't this exactly what you just did?

 

Regarding the 208 - The official Euro NCAP datasheets shows marks high enough fot 5 stars in adult and child protection, narrowly missing the 5th star only for pedestrian protection. The organization’s press release reiterates this: "The Peugeot 208 narrowly misses out on a five-star rating, so drops a star compared to the previous-generation vehicle, that offered fewer standard safety technology but was tested against less stringent requirements in 2012. The supermini meets the five-star requirements in all areas except the protection of vulnerable road users, so ends up with a four-star rating overall." (Meaning pedestrians).

 

The quote by Autocar is therefor quite strange and contradicts the official press release and data sheet.

9 October 2019

If it's the former, then this is less easily fixed, since it may involve sheet metal changes at the front. It will be interesting to see if peugeot can address this and whether the new Corsa has the same issue.  

9 October 2019

I like the 208 but it seems a poor effort that you have to go to GT line to get night function on the pedestrian detection, as that is when I would have thought you need it most and it should be standard on all cars.

9 October 2019

Who cares about NCAP?  We want SPAM!

9 October 2019
eseaton wrote:

Who cares about NCAP?  We want SPAM!

I made $42468 in the last 2 hours selling Spam to my local Spar. I spent $42469 on finding my perfect sex partner on line. Misery.

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week